{ "contract": { "endpoint": "/api/ctst/saddlescope", "svgEndpoint": "/api/ctst/saddlescope/svg", "consoleEndpoint": "/console/ctst/saddlescope", "contractVersion": "pinto_ctst_saddlescope/v1", "sourceContract": "ctst_saddle_scope_receipts/v1", "source": "ctst.pinto.saddlescope.admissibility_evidence_meo_topology_matsci", "renderer": "pinto_ctst_saddlescope_svg/v1", "payloadBoundary": "hash_safe_receipts_only_no_material_permission_no_truth_claim", "pinfoSurface": "pinfo.svv_ctst_saddlescope", "psketchFamily": "ctst_saddlescope", "requiredRowFields": [ "ts", "node_id", "edge_id", "type", "value", "sketch_family", "confidence", "entity", "is_outlier", "severity" ], "requiredGovernanceFields": [ "owner", "review_cycle", "review_due", "jurisdiction", "declared_grain", "reviewers", "supersedes", "superseded_by", "review_events", "absence_kind", "rev_oracle_version", "nature_trace" ], "absenceOntology": { "VOID": "no value exists; an ontological absence carved by subtraction", "GHOST": "value unknown; an epistemic absence", "verdict": "exactly one current value; decidable at the declared grain", "SADDLEPIT": "too many contradictory values; an undecidable saturation hole carved by addition" }, "saddlepitDiagnostics": { "glut_mean": "local contradiction fraction", "glut_kurtosis": "fourth-moment concentration of contradictions; high means common-cause localization", "ess": "effective sample size after confidence and decay weighting", "l_kurtosis": "small-sample-stable L-kurtosis scout, preferred over raw fourth moment for live jitter control", "dip_test": "bimodality discriminator separating real nulls from two-mode saddlepits", "spectral_gap": "leading-mode separation in K_g; collapse indicates REV near-degeneracy", "percolation_margin": "distance from decidable-surface disconnection", "cause_attachment": "mint_run_nogood, rev_near_degeneracy, per_cell, or unexplained", "rev_feedback": "none, coarsen_or_split_requested, or revision_damping" }, "natureGenerator": { "posture": "author_the_latent_process_not_the_saddlepit_branch", "seed": "paretosol:nature-saddlepit:v1:batch-effect", "groundTruth": "regions contain k latent sub-populations with verdict directions s_j and reaction-coordinate positions xi_j", "receiptEmission": "draw hidden sub-population, emit weighted aged grain-tagged sign with Student-t noise nu=ESS and source_confidence observed>derived>asserted", "emergentRead": "pool receipts at grain g, compute weighted mean, ESS, L-kurtosis, dip-test posture, spectral gap, then classify", "classMap": [ "tight_unimodal_nonzero_mean => verdict", "heavy_tail_low_ESS_that_washes_out => GHOST", "opposite_nearby_modes_kurtosis_survives_ESS => SADDLEPIT", "no_samples_possible_at_grain => VOID" ], "surfaces": [ "landscape_position_from_mu_and_kurtosis", "REV_ladder_from_delta_g_avoided_crossing", "coarsen_grain_drain_from_rebinning_past_REV", "time_machine_from_knowledge_from_order", "microtheory_seam_from_disorientation" ], "invariants": [ "drain_monotonicity_kurtosis_nonincreasing_past_REV", "ESS_washout_distinguishes_GHOST_from_SADDLEPIT", "sign_symmetry_requires_near_null_mean_for_SADDLEPIT", "same_seed_and_url_hash_yield_bit_identical_ensemble", "class_map_total_and_single_valued" ], "caveat": "nature trace is scout evidence; it explains the demo generator and does not certify material truth" }, "governanceProcess": [ { "external": "Intake", "saddlescope": "New receipt enters as OPEN" }, { "external": "Triage", "saddlescope": "Assign receipt family, owner, jurisdiction, and declared grain" }, { "external": "Evidence review", "saddlescope": "Evaluate receipt density, replication, provenance, REV/MEO posture, and glut-kurtosis" }, { "external": "Board review", "saddlescope": "Decide SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE / WITHHELD / REJECTED / OPEN / SADDLEPIT" }, { "external": "Action items", "saddlescope": "Populate next_evidence_needed and assign owner" }, { "external": "Re-review", "saddlescope": "Reopen automatically when new receipt refs arrive" }, { "external": "Audit", "saddlescope": "Preserve every state transition as append-only receipt events" } ], "reviewEventTypes": [ "OBSERVED", "CLASSIFIED", "REVIEWED", "WITHHELD", "REJECTED", "OPEN", "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "SADDLEPIT", "NEW_EVIDENCE", "REV_FEEDBACK_REQUESTED" ], "receiptFamilies": [ "permission", "evidence", "ladder", "open_axis", "active_meo", "topology", "matsci", "saddlepit" ], "permissionStates": [ "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "WITHHELD", "REJECTED", "OPEN", "SADDLEPIT" ], "decisionStates": [ "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "WITHHELD", "REJECTED", "OPEN", "SADDLEPIT" ], "scoutBands": [ "q", "kappa", "MEO" ], "bandDefinitions": { "q": { "label": "committor-like scout coordinate", "range": [ 0, 1 ], "unit": "unitless_scout", "caveat": "not a measured probability until backed by a declared calculation and uncertainty receipt" }, "kappa": { "label": "recrossing / survival scout band", "range": [ 0, 1 ], "unit": "unitless_scout", "caveat": "not a transmission coefficient until method, repeats, and confidence interval are declared" }, "MEO": { "label": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "range": [ 0, 1 ], "unit": "unitless_scout", "caveat": "not explanation authority; it marks whether the smallest useful observation has been named" } }, "evidenceLayerOrder": [ "observations", "derived_quantities", "workflow_decision" ], "observationDecisionSeparation": "observations_and_review_events_are_append_only_decisions_are_current_posture", "nonClaims": [ "q_band_is_a_scout_band_not_truth", "kappa_band_is_a_scout_band_not_truth", "MEO_band_is_a_scout_band_not_truth", "pinto_visualization_does_not_grant_material_permission", "open_axis_receipts_are_questions_not_resolution", "review_board_posture_is_epistemic_process_not_certification_authority", "saddlepit_names_contradiction_saturation_not_truth_or_certification" ] }, "frame": { "generated_at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "mode": "ctst_saddlescope", "scene": "matsci_receipt_wall", "contract_version": "pinto_ctst_saddlescope/v1", "source": "ctst.pinto.saddlescope.admissibility_evidence_meo_topology_matsci", "source_contract": "ctst_saddle_scope_receipts/v1", "source_surface": "ctst.pinto.saddlescope.admissibility_evidence_meo_topology_matsci", "evidence_grade": "scout", "redaction_posture": "hash_or_class_only", "freshness": { "status": "fixture_fresh_for_visual_review", "generated_at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "ttl_seconds": 86400, "rev_status": "SCOUT_REV" }, "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "authority_boundary": "visual_scout_only_no_material_permission_no_truth_claim", "forbidden_use_text": "Do not treat q, kappa, or MEO bands as truth, material certification, or permission to act.", "privacy_mode": "redacted_hash_class_count_only", "payload_boundary": "hash_safe_receipts_only_no_material_permission_no_truth_claim", "pinfo_surface": "pinfo.svv_ctst_saddlescope", "psketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "permission_states": [ "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "WITHHELD", "REJECTED", "OPEN", "SADDLEPIT" ], "decision_states": [ "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "WITHHELD", "REJECTED", "OPEN", "SADDLEPIT" ], "receipt_families": [ "permission", "evidence", "ladder", "open_axis", "active_meo", "topology", "matsci", "saddlepit" ], "absence_ontology": { "VOID": "no value exists; an ontological absence carved by subtraction", "GHOST": "value unknown; an epistemic absence", "verdict": "exactly one current value; decidable at the declared grain", "SADDLEPIT": "too many contradictory values; an undecidable saturation hole carved by addition" }, "saddlepit_diagnostics_contract": { "glut_mean": "local contradiction fraction", "glut_kurtosis": "fourth-moment concentration of contradictions; high means common-cause localization", "ess": "effective sample size after confidence and decay weighting", "l_kurtosis": "small-sample-stable L-kurtosis scout, preferred over raw fourth moment for live jitter control", "dip_test": "bimodality discriminator separating real nulls from two-mode saddlepits", "spectral_gap": "leading-mode separation in K_g; collapse indicates REV near-degeneracy", "percolation_margin": "distance from decidable-surface disconnection", "cause_attachment": "mint_run_nogood, rev_near_degeneracy, per_cell, or unexplained", "rev_feedback": "none, coarsen_or_split_requested, or revision_damping" }, "nature_generator": { "posture": "author_the_latent_process_not_the_saddlepit_branch", "seed": "paretosol:nature-saddlepit:v1:batch-effect", "groundTruth": "regions contain k latent sub-populations with verdict directions s_j and reaction-coordinate positions xi_j", "receiptEmission": "draw hidden sub-population, emit weighted aged grain-tagged sign with Student-t noise nu=ESS and source_confidence observed>derived>asserted", "emergentRead": "pool receipts at grain g, compute weighted mean, ESS, L-kurtosis, dip-test posture, spectral gap, then classify", "classMap": [ "tight_unimodal_nonzero_mean => verdict", "heavy_tail_low_ESS_that_washes_out => GHOST", "opposite_nearby_modes_kurtosis_survives_ESS => SADDLEPIT", "no_samples_possible_at_grain => VOID" ], "surfaces": [ "landscape_position_from_mu_and_kurtosis", "REV_ladder_from_delta_g_avoided_crossing", "coarsen_grain_drain_from_rebinning_past_REV", "time_machine_from_knowledge_from_order", "microtheory_seam_from_disorientation" ], "invariants": [ "drain_monotonicity_kurtosis_nonincreasing_past_REV", "ESS_washout_distinguishes_GHOST_from_SADDLEPIT", "sign_symmetry_requires_near_null_mean_for_SADDLEPIT", "same_seed_and_url_hash_yield_bit_identical_ensemble", "class_map_total_and_single_valued" ], "caveat": "nature trace is scout evidence; it explains the demo generator and does not certify material truth" }, "nature_seed": "paretosol:nature-saddlepit:v1:batch-effect", "scout_bands": [ "q", "kappa", "MEO" ], "band_definitions": { "q": { "label": "committor-like scout coordinate", "range": [ 0, 1 ], "unit": "unitless_scout", "caveat": "not a measured probability until backed by a declared calculation and uncertainty receipt" }, "kappa": { "label": "recrossing / survival scout band", "range": [ 0, 1 ], "unit": "unitless_scout", "caveat": "not a transmission coefficient until method, repeats, and confidence interval are declared" }, "MEO": { "label": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "range": [ 0, 1 ], "unit": "unitless_scout", "caveat": "not explanation authority; it marks whether the smallest useful observation has been named" } }, "evidence_layer_order": [ "observations", "derived_quantities", "workflow_decision" ], "governance_process": [ { "external": "Intake", "saddlescope": "New receipt enters as OPEN" }, { "external": "Triage", "saddlescope": "Assign receipt family, owner, jurisdiction, and declared grain" }, { "external": "Evidence review", "saddlescope": "Evaluate receipt density, replication, provenance, REV/MEO posture, and glut-kurtosis" }, { "external": "Board review", "saddlescope": "Decide SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE / WITHHELD / REJECTED / OPEN / SADDLEPIT" }, { "external": "Action items", "saddlescope": "Populate next_evidence_needed and assign owner" }, { "external": "Re-review", "saddlescope": "Reopen automatically when new receipt refs arrive" }, { "external": "Audit", "saddlescope": "Preserve every state transition as append-only receipt events" } ], "review_event_types": [ "OBSERVED", "CLASSIFIED", "REVIEWED", "WITHHELD", "REJECTED", "OPEN", "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "SADDLEPIT", "NEW_EVIDENCE", "REV_FEEDBACK_REQUESTED" ], "observation_decision_separation": "observations_and_review_events_are_append_only_decisions_are_current_posture", "audit_posture": "append_only_review_events_preserve_state_transitions", "rev_feedback_posture": "high_local_glut_kurtosis_requests_REV_coarsen_or_split_not_claim_promotion", "revision_damping_posture": "do_not_revise_regions_while_glut_kurtosis_is_still_rising_from_last_revision", "scout_band_posture": "q_kappa_MEO_are_scout_bands_not_truth", "material_action_authority": false, "truth_claim_authority": false, "state_counts": { "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE": 2, "WITHHELD": 2, "REJECTED": 1, "OPEN": 2, "SADDLEPIT": 1 }, "status_palette": { "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE": "#2fbf71", "WITHHELD": "#f2c94c", "REJECTED": "#ef5b5b", "OPEN": "#56cfe1", "SADDLEPIT": "#c084fc" }, "receipts": [ { "id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "family": "permission", "label": "coupon bridge admissibility", "state": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "question": "May this reviewed coupon bridge be used as a scout exemplar?", "q": 0.68, "kappa": 0.61, "MEO": 0.74, "observations": [ "identity continuity PASS", "REV PASS", "jurisdiction PASS", "topology conflicts none" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "identity continuity PASS", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "REV PASS", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:rev" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "jurisdiction PASS", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:jurisdiction" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 3, "observation": "topology conflicts none", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity" } ], "evidence": [ "receipt signed", "scope bounded", "redaction clean" ], "absence_kind": "verdict", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "owner": "materials", "review_cycle": 3, "review_due": "2026-07-28", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "coupon_bridge", "reviewers": [ "materials", "statistics" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "family:permission", "basis": "owner=materials; grain=coupon_bridge", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "NEW_EVIDENCE", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:jurisdiction", "basis": "additional receipt arrived before board review", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "identity_continuity_pass; scope_bounded; redaction_clean; no_material_action_authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "identity_continuity_pass", "scope_bounded", "redaction_clean", "no_material_action_authority" ], "decision_explanation": "scope-bounded, redaction-clean receipt is admissible to the scout wall", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "replicate coupon", "owner boundary refresh" ], "thresholds": [ "identity continuity >= pass", "REV >= reviewed scout", "conflict count = 0" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity", "receipt:coupon_bridge:rev", "receipt:coupon_bridge:jurisdiction" ], "caveat": "scout-admissible means display admissible, not material or safety permission", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.68, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.61, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.74, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true }, { "id": "evidence_interface_gap", "family": "evidence", "label": "interface gap evidence", "state": "WITHHELD", "question": "Is the interface gap backed by enough receipt density?", "q": 0.44, "kappa": 0.36, "MEO": 0.52, "observations": [ "one microscopy trace", "interface A/B bridge not characterized" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "one microscopy trace", "source_ref": "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "interface A/B bridge not characterized", "source_ref": "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001" } ], "evidence": [ "one microscopy trace", "missing replicate", "no owner boundary" ], "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "owner": "process", "review_cycle": 2, "review_due": "2026-07-16", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "interface", "reviewers": [ "materials", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "process", "evidence_ref": "family:evidence", "basis": "owner=process; grain=interface", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "interface_bridge_missing; replicate_count_below_threshold; owner_boundary_absent", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "WITHHELD", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:WITHHELD", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "interface_bridge_missing", "replicate_count_below_threshold", "owner_boundary_absent" ], "decision_explanation": "withheld until second receipt closes variance", "missing_evidence": [ "second microscopy receipt", "owner boundary", "interface bridge characterization" ], "next_evidence_needed": [ "second microscopy receipt", "replicate coupon", "owner boundary" ], "thresholds": [ "replicate_count >= 2 required for admissible display" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001" ], "caveat": "withhold until second receipt closes variance", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.44, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.36, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.52, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true }, { "id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "family": "ladder", "label": "half REV ladder jump", "state": "OPEN", "question": "Does half REV explain the observed scale transition?", "q": 0.51, "kappa": 0.47, "MEO": 0.58, "observations": [ "declared grain coupon", "observed grain interface band", "REV delta crosses one half-rung" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "declared grain coupon", "source_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "observed grain interface band", "source_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_observed" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "REV delta crosses one half-rung", "source_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared" } ], "evidence": [ "scale rung named", "recrossing untested", "MEO candidate active" ], "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "owner": "statistics", "review_cycle": 1, "review_due": "2026-07-08", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "REV_half_rung", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "materials" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "statistics", "evidence_ref": "family:ladder", "basis": "owner=statistics; grain=REV_half_rung", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "declared_grain_coupon; observed_grain_interface_band; half_rev_delta_detected; recrossing_untested", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "OPEN", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:OPEN", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "declared_grain_coupon", "observed_grain_interface_band", "half_rev_delta_detected", "recrossing_untested" ], "decision_explanation": "open because recrossing survival is untested; half marks a partial REV grain shift, not a promotion", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "recrossing survival check", "grain repeat receipt" ], "thresholds": [ "REV_delta between 0.4 and 0.6 rung => half_REV" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared", "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_observed" ], "caveat": "open rung, not a certified transition", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.51, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.47, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.58, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true }, { "id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "family": "open_axis", "label": "formula owner axis", "state": "OPEN", "question": "Which owner can close the formula axis?", "q": 0.29, "kappa": 0.22, "MEO": 0.41, "observations": [ "formula owner absent", "rule predicate absent", "freshness bounded" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "formula owner absent", "source_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "rule predicate absent", "source_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "freshness bounded", "source_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" } ], "evidence": [ "owner absent", "rule predicate absent", "freshness bounded" ], "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "owner": "governance", "review_cycle": 1, "review_due": "2026-07-08", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "authority_axis", "reviewers": [ "process", "audit" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "governance", "evidence_ref": "family:open_axis", "basis": "owner=governance; grain=authority_axis", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "authority_owner_unknown; rule_predicate_absent; review_question_must_stay_visible", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "OPEN", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:OPEN", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "authority_owner_unknown", "rule_predicate_absent", "review_question_must_stay_visible" ], "decision_explanation": "open because the authority owner is unknown and the question must stay visible to reviewers", "missing_evidence": [ "named owner", "rule predicate", "freshness receipt refresh" ], "next_evidence_needed": [ "named owner", "rule predicate", "freshness receipt refresh" ], "thresholds": [ "named_authority required before closure" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" ], "caveat": "open axis must remain visible", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.29, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.22, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.41, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true }, { "id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "family": "active_meo", "label": "metric inversion MEO", "state": "REJECTED", "question": "Can the candidate MEO be treated as explanatory?", "q": 0.18, "kappa": 0.14, "MEO": 0.33, "observations": [ "expected monotonicity depth -> modulus", "observed inversion at edge band", "route recrosses" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "expected monotonicity depth -> modulus", "source_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "observed inversion at edge band", "source_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:counterexample" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "route recrosses", "source_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity" } ], "evidence": [ "counterexample exists", "metric formula unstable", "route recrosses" ], "absence_kind": "verdict", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "owner": "statistics", "review_cycle": 2, "review_due": "2026-07-23", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "metric_path", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "statistics", "evidence_ref": "family:active_meo", "basis": "owner=statistics; grain=metric_path", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "expected_monotonicity_declared; observed_metric_inversion; threshold_breached; negative_control_retained", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REJECTED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:REJECTED", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "expected_monotonicity_declared", "observed_metric_inversion", "threshold_breached", "negative_control_retained" ], "decision_explanation": "rejected, but retained as negative control", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "repeat metric path", "alternate coordinate check" ], "thresholds": [ "expected slope sign stable", "observed sign flip => reject" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity", "receipt:meo_metric:counterexample" ], "caveat": "reject as explanation, keep as negative control", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.18, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.14, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.33, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true }, { "id": "topology_cycle_current", "family": "topology", "label": "cycle-current topology", "state": "WITHHELD", "question": "Does the topology carry a true detailed-balance break?", "q": 0.56, "kappa": 0.39, "MEO": 0.49, "observations": [ "cycle substrate present", "entropy production positive", "eigenvector alignment thin" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "cycle substrate present", "source_ref": "receipt:topology:cycle_current" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "entropy production positive", "source_ref": "receipt:topology:entropy_positive" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "eigenvector alignment thin", "source_ref": "receipt:topology:cycle_current" } ], "evidence": [ "cycle substrate present", "entropy production positive", "alignment thin" ], "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "owner": "process", "review_cycle": 2, "review_due": "2026-07-16", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "topology_cycle", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:topology:cycle_current", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "process", "evidence_ref": "family:topology", "basis": "owner=process; grain=topology_cycle", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "residual_eigenvector_disagreement; local_topology_not_global_coordinate_authority; coordinate_lens_review_missing", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "WITHHELD", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:WITHHELD", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "residual_eigenvector_disagreement", "local_topology_not_global_coordinate_authority", "coordinate_lens_review_missing" ], "decision_explanation": "withheld because residual and eigenvector checks disagree", "missing_evidence": [ "residual agreement", "eigenvector agreement", "coordinate-lens review" ], "next_evidence_needed": [ "residual agreement", "eigenvector agreement", "coordinate-lens review" ], "thresholds": [ "residual_check PASS and eigenvector_check PASS required" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:topology:cycle_current", "receipt:topology:entropy_positive" ], "caveat": "withhold until residual and eigenvector checks agree", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.56, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.39, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.49, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true }, { "id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "family": "matsci", "label": "nylon ceramic coupon", "state": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "question": "May MatSci coupon receipts seed the visual scout?", "q": 0.73, "kappa": 0.66, "MEO": 0.69, "observations": [ "coupon nylon_ceramic_002 scanned", "moisture uptake band bounded", "material class nylon ceramic bridge" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "coupon nylon_ceramic_002 scanned", "source_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "moisture uptake band bounded", "source_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:moisture_band" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "material class nylon ceramic bridge", "source_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002" } ], "evidence": [ "coupon receipt", "material class bounded", "no certification claim" ], "absence_kind": "verdict", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "owner": "materials", "review_cycle": 3, "review_due": "2026-07-28", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "coupon_interface", "reviewers": [ "materials", "statistics", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "family:matsci", "basis": "owner=materials; grain=coupon_interface", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "NEW_EVIDENCE", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:moisture_band", "basis": "additional receipt arrived before board review", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "coupon_receipt_present; material_family_declared; certification_claim_absent; no_material_action_authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "coupon_receipt_present", "material_family_declared", "certification_claim_absent", "no_material_action_authority" ], "decision_explanation": "scout-admissible; not a material certificate", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "replicate coupon", "method uncertainty receipt" ], "thresholds": [ "coupon receipt present", "material family declared", "certification claim absent" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002", "receipt:matsci_coupon:moisture_band" ], "caveat": "not a material certificate", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.73, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.66, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.69, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true }, { "id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "family": "saddlepit", "label": "REV boundary saddlepit", "state": "SADDLEPIT", "question": "Is this region undecidable because evidence is missing, or because too much contradictory evidence piled up?", "q": 0.37, "kappa": 0.19, "MEO": 0.64, "observations": [ "localized contradiction pile-up", "glut-kurtosis high while mean remains low", "spectral gap of K_g collapsed", "microtheory boundary disorientation high" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "localized contradiction pile-up", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "glut-kurtosis high while mean remains low", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:spectral_gap_Kg" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "spectral gap of K_g collapsed", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:percolation_guard" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 3, "observation": "microtheory boundary disorientation high", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster" } ], "evidence": [ "contradiction cluster", "near-degenerate leading modes", "REV oracle likely optimistic" ], "absence_kind": "SADDLEPIT", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0.18, "glut_kurtosis": 11.6, "ess": 18.4, "l_kurtosis": 0.64, "dip_test": "bimodal", "spectral_gap": 0.03, "percolation_margin": 0.17, "cause_attachment": "rev_near_degeneracy", "rev_feedback": "coarsen_or_split_requested", "revision_damping": "hold_new_oracle_revision_until_spectral_gap_restabilizes", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "paretosol:nature-saddlepit:v1:batch-effect", "generator_posture": "author_the_latent_process_not_the_saddlepit_branch", "latent_mode_count": 2, "mode_story": "batch_effect_same_question_overasked_at_too_fine_grain", "latent_subpopulations": [ { "id": "batch_alpha", "pi": 0.52, "verdict_direction": 1, "xi": 0.492 }, { "id": "batch_beta", "pi": 0.48, "verdict_direction": -1, "xi": 0.508 } ], "receipt_emission": "categorical_subpopulation_then_student_t_sign_noise_with_nu_equals_ESS_weighted_by_confidence_and_decay", "clocks": [ "valid_from", "knowledge_from" ], "source_confidence_weights": { "observed": 1, "derived": 0.62, "asserted": 0.28 }, "decay_bands": [ "R0", "R1", "R2", "R3", "R4", "R5", "R6" ], "spectral_gap_curve": [ { "grain": "g_fine", "delta_g": 0.03, "leading_vector": "unstable" }, { "grain": "g_mid", "delta_g": 0.08, "leading_vector": "flipping" }, { "grain": "g_rev_fixed_point", "delta_g": 0.31, "leading_vector": "stable" } ], "moment_reads": [ { "grain": "g_fine", "resolves_subpopulations": true, "mu": 0.02, "ess": 18.4, "excess_kurtosis": 11.6, "l_kurtosis": 0.64, "dip_test": "bimodal", "spectral_gap": 0.03, "classification": "SADDLEPIT" }, { "grain": "g_rev_fixed_point", "resolves_subpopulations": false, "mu": 0.04, "ess": 21.2, "excess_kurtosis": 0.72, "l_kurtosis": 0.08, "dip_test": "unimodal", "spectral_gap": 0.31, "classification": "verdict" } ], "drain_path": [ { "grain": "g_fine", "classification": "SADDLEPIT", "excess_kurtosis": 11.6, "spectral_gap": 0.03 }, { "grain": "g_rev_fixed_point", "classification": "verdict", "excess_kurtosis": 0.72, "spectral_gap": 0.31 } ], "time_machine": [ { "knowledge_fraction": 0.25, "classification": "GHOST", "ess": 4.8, "excess_kurtosis": 7.1 }, { "knowledge_fraction": 0.55, "classification": "SADDLEPIT", "ess": 10.6, "excess_kurtosis": 10.4 }, { "knowledge_fraction": 1, "classification": "SADDLEPIT", "ess": 18.4, "excess_kurtosis": 11.6 } ], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "pass", "ess_washout": "kurtosis_persists_as_ESS_grows", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "pass", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true, "coarsen_past_REV_drains": true }, "falsifier": "if coarsening past REV does not reduce kurtosis, the generator or REV curve is wrong" }, "owner": "rev_oracle", "review_cycle": 1, "review_due": "2026-07-04", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "microtheory_boundary", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "process", "audit" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "rev_oracle", "evidence_ref": "family:saddlepit", "basis": "owner=rev_oracle; grain=microtheory_boundary", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "low_mean_high_kurtosis; spectral_gap_collapsed; rev_oracle_feedback_required; revision_damping_until_gap_restabilizes", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REV_FEEDBACK_REQUESTED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "rev_oracle:coarsen_or_split", "basis": "glut-kurtosis localized and spectral gap collapsed", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "SADDLEPIT", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:SADDLEPIT", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "decision_basis": [ "low_mean_high_kurtosis", "spectral_gap_collapsed", "rev_oracle_feedback_required", "revision_damping_until_gap_restabilizes" ], "decision_explanation": "saddlepit: refuse because evidence is overfull and contradictory, not because data is merely absent", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "nogood detector run if common-cause", "coarsen or split REV", "hold revisions until spectral gap restabilizes" ], "thresholds": [ "glut_mean < 0.25 and glut_kurtosis >= 8 => early saddlepit alarm", "spectral_gap <= 0.05 => REV near-degeneracy", "percolation_margin <= 0.20 => decidable-surface disconnection risk" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster", "receipt:saddlepit:spectral_gap_Kg", "receipt:saddlepit:percolation_guard" ], "caveat": "SADDLEPIT is a refusal state, not proof that any contradicted claim is false", "derived_quantities": { "q": { "value": 0.37, "definition": "committor-like scout coordinate", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "kappa": { "value": 0.19, "definition": "recrossing / survival scout band", "unit": "unitless_scout" }, "MEO": { "value": 0.64, "definition": "minimum explanatory observation scout", "unit": "unitless_scout" } }, "permitted_to_act": false, "truth_claim": false, "visible_on_scope": true } ], "rows": [ { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "edge_id": "permission", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.permission.scout_admissible", "value": 0.74, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.74, "entity": "coupon bridge admissibility", "is_outlier": false, "severity": 0, "receipt_family": "permission", "permission_state": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "decision_state": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "owner": "materials", "absence_kind": "verdict", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "review_cycle": 3, "review_due": "2026-07-28", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "coupon_bridge", "reviewers": [ "materials", "statistics" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "identity continuity PASS", "REV PASS", "jurisdiction PASS", "topology conflicts none" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "identity continuity PASS", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "REV PASS", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:rev" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "jurisdiction PASS", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:jurisdiction" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 3, "observation": "topology conflicts none", "source_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity" } ], "decision_basis": [ "identity_continuity_pass", "scope_bounded", "redaction_clean", "no_material_action_authority" ], "decision_explanation": "scope-bounded, redaction-clean receipt is admissible to the scout wall", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "replicate coupon", "owner boundary refresh" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "family:permission", "basis": "owner=materials; grain=coupon_bridge", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "NEW_EVIDENCE", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "receipt:coupon_bridge:jurisdiction", "basis": "additional receipt arrived before board review", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "identity_continuity_pass; scope_bounded; redaction_clean; no_material_action_authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "receipt_id": "permission_direct_coupon_bridge", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "identity continuity >= pass", "REV >= reviewed scout", "conflict count = 0" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:coupon_bridge:identity", "receipt:coupon_bridge:rev", "receipt:coupon_bridge:jurisdiction" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" }, { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "edge_id": "evidence", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.evidence.withheld", "value": 0.52, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.52, "entity": "interface gap evidence", "is_outlier": true, "severity": 2, "receipt_family": "evidence", "permission_state": "WITHHELD", "decision_state": "WITHHELD", "owner": "process", "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "review_cycle": 2, "review_due": "2026-07-16", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "interface", "reviewers": [ "materials", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "one microscopy trace", "interface A/B bridge not characterized" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "one microscopy trace", "source_ref": "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "interface A/B bridge not characterized", "source_ref": "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001" } ], "decision_basis": [ "interface_bridge_missing", "replicate_count_below_threshold", "owner_boundary_absent" ], "decision_explanation": "withheld until second receipt closes variance", "missing_evidence": [ "second microscopy receipt", "owner boundary", "interface bridge characterization" ], "next_evidence_needed": [ "second microscopy receipt", "replicate coupon", "owner boundary" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "process", "evidence_ref": "family:evidence", "basis": "owner=process; grain=interface", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "interface_bridge_missing; replicate_count_below_threshold; owner_boundary_absent", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "WITHHELD", "receipt_id": "evidence_interface_gap", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:WITHHELD", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "replicate_count >= 2 required for admissible display" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:interface_gap:microscopy_001" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" }, { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "edge_id": "ladder", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.ladder.open", "value": 0.58, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.58, "entity": "half REV ladder jump", "is_outlier": false, "severity": 1, "receipt_family": "ladder", "permission_state": "OPEN", "decision_state": "OPEN", "owner": "statistics", "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "review_cycle": 1, "review_due": "2026-07-08", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "REV_half_rung", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "materials" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "declared grain coupon", "observed grain interface band", "REV delta crosses one half-rung" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "declared grain coupon", "source_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "observed grain interface band", "source_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_observed" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "REV delta crosses one half-rung", "source_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared" } ], "decision_basis": [ "declared_grain_coupon", "observed_grain_interface_band", "half_rev_delta_detected", "recrossing_untested" ], "decision_explanation": "open because recrossing survival is untested; half marks a partial REV grain shift, not a promotion", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "recrossing survival check", "grain repeat receipt" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "statistics", "evidence_ref": "family:ladder", "basis": "owner=statistics; grain=REV_half_rung", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "declared_grain_coupon; observed_grain_interface_band; half_rev_delta_detected; recrossing_untested", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "OPEN", "receipt_id": "ladder_half_rev_jump", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:OPEN", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "REV_delta between 0.4 and 0.6 rung => half_REV" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_declared", "receipt:rev_ladder:grain_observed" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" }, { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "edge_id": "open_axis", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.open_axis.open", "value": 0.41, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.41, "entity": "formula owner axis", "is_outlier": false, "severity": 1, "receipt_family": "open_axis", "permission_state": "OPEN", "decision_state": "OPEN", "owner": "governance", "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "review_cycle": 1, "review_due": "2026-07-08", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "authority_axis", "reviewers": [ "process", "audit" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "formula owner absent", "rule predicate absent", "freshness bounded" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "formula owner absent", "source_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "rule predicate absent", "source_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "freshness bounded", "source_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" } ], "decision_basis": [ "authority_owner_unknown", "rule_predicate_absent", "review_question_must_stay_visible" ], "decision_explanation": "open because the authority owner is unknown and the question must stay visible to reviewers", "missing_evidence": [ "named owner", "rule predicate", "freshness receipt refresh" ], "next_evidence_needed": [ "named owner", "rule predicate", "freshness receipt refresh" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:formula_axis:freshness", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "governance", "evidence_ref": "family:open_axis", "basis": "owner=governance; grain=authority_axis", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "authority_owner_unknown; rule_predicate_absent; review_question_must_stay_visible", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "OPEN", "receipt_id": "open_axis_formula_owner", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:OPEN", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "named_authority required before closure" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:formula_axis:freshness" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" }, { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "edge_id": "active_meo", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.active_meo.rejected", "value": 0.33, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.33, "entity": "metric inversion MEO", "is_outlier": true, "severity": 3, "receipt_family": "active_meo", "permission_state": "REJECTED", "decision_state": "REJECTED", "owner": "statistics", "absence_kind": "verdict", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "review_cycle": 2, "review_due": "2026-07-23", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "metric_path", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "expected monotonicity depth -> modulus", "observed inversion at edge band", "route recrosses" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "expected monotonicity depth -> modulus", "source_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "observed inversion at edge band", "source_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:counterexample" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "route recrosses", "source_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity" } ], "decision_basis": [ "expected_monotonicity_declared", "observed_metric_inversion", "threshold_breached", "negative_control_retained" ], "decision_explanation": "rejected, but retained as negative control", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "repeat metric path", "alternate coordinate check" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "statistics", "evidence_ref": "family:active_meo", "basis": "owner=statistics; grain=metric_path", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "expected_monotonicity_declared; observed_metric_inversion; threshold_breached; negative_control_retained", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REJECTED", "receipt_id": "active_meo_metric_inversion", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:REJECTED", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "expected slope sign stable", "observed sign flip => reject" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:meo_metric:monotonicity", "receipt:meo_metric:counterexample" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" }, { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "topology_cycle_current", "edge_id": "topology", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.topology.withheld", "value": 0.49, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.56, "entity": "cycle-current topology", "is_outlier": true, "severity": 2, "receipt_family": "topology", "permission_state": "WITHHELD", "decision_state": "WITHHELD", "owner": "process", "absence_kind": "GHOST", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "review_cycle": 2, "review_due": "2026-07-16", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "topology_cycle", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "cycle substrate present", "entropy production positive", "eigenvector alignment thin" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "cycle substrate present", "source_ref": "receipt:topology:cycle_current" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "entropy production positive", "source_ref": "receipt:topology:entropy_positive" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "eigenvector alignment thin", "source_ref": "receipt:topology:cycle_current" } ], "decision_basis": [ "residual_eigenvector_disagreement", "local_topology_not_global_coordinate_authority", "coordinate_lens_review_missing" ], "decision_explanation": "withheld because residual and eigenvector checks disagree", "missing_evidence": [ "residual agreement", "eigenvector agreement", "coordinate-lens review" ], "next_evidence_needed": [ "residual agreement", "eigenvector agreement", "coordinate-lens review" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:topology:cycle_current", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "process", "evidence_ref": "family:topology", "basis": "owner=process; grain=topology_cycle", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "residual_eigenvector_disagreement; local_topology_not_global_coordinate_authority; coordinate_lens_review_missing", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "WITHHELD", "receipt_id": "topology_cycle_current", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:WITHHELD", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "residual_check PASS and eigenvector_check PASS required" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:topology:cycle_current", "receipt:topology:entropy_positive" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" }, { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "edge_id": "matsci", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.matsci.scout_admissible", "value": 0.69, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.73, "entity": "nylon ceramic coupon", "is_outlier": false, "severity": 0, "receipt_family": "matsci", "permission_state": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "decision_state": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "owner": "materials", "absence_kind": "verdict", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0, "glut_kurtosis": 0, "spectral_gap": 1, "percolation_margin": 1, "cause_attachment": "none", "rev_feedback": "none", "revision_damping": "none", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "none", "generator_posture": "no_saddlepit_generator_active", "latent_mode_count": 1, "mode_story": "tight_unimodal", "latent_subpopulations": [], "receipt_emission": "not_applicable", "moment_reads": [], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "not_applicable", "ess_washout": "not_applicable", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "not_applicable", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true } }, "review_cycle": 3, "review_due": "2026-07-28", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "coupon_interface", "reviewers": [ "materials", "statistics", "process" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "coupon nylon_ceramic_002 scanned", "moisture uptake band bounded", "material class nylon ceramic bridge" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "coupon nylon_ceramic_002 scanned", "source_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "moisture uptake band bounded", "source_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:moisture_band" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "material class nylon ceramic bridge", "source_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002" } ], "decision_basis": [ "coupon_receipt_present", "material_family_declared", "certification_claim_absent", "no_material_action_authority" ], "decision_explanation": "scout-admissible; not a material certificate", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "replicate coupon", "method uncertainty receipt" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "family:matsci", "basis": "owner=materials; grain=coupon_interface", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "NEW_EVIDENCE", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "materials", "evidence_ref": "receipt:matsci_coupon:moisture_band", "basis": "additional receipt arrived before board review", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "coupon_receipt_present; material_family_declared; certification_claim_absent; no_material_action_authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "receipt_id": "matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "coupon receipt present", "material family declared", "certification claim absent" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:matsci_coupon:nylon_ceramic_002", "receipt:matsci_coupon:moisture_band" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" }, { "ts": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "node_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "edge_id": "saddlepit", "type": "ctst.saddlescope.saddlepit.saddlepit", "value": 0.64, "sketch_family": "ctst_saddlescope", "confidence": 0.64, "entity": "REV boundary saddlepit", "is_outlier": true, "severity": 3, "receipt_family": "saddlepit", "permission_state": "SADDLEPIT", "decision_state": "SADDLEPIT", "owner": "rev_oracle", "absence_kind": "SADDLEPIT", "rev_oracle_version": "rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11", "saddlepit_diagnostics": { "glut_mean": 0.18, "glut_kurtosis": 11.6, "ess": 18.4, "l_kurtosis": 0.64, "dip_test": "bimodal", "spectral_gap": 0.03, "percolation_margin": 0.17, "cause_attachment": "rev_near_degeneracy", "rev_feedback": "coarsen_or_split_requested", "revision_damping": "hold_new_oracle_revision_until_spectral_gap_restabilizes", "unexplained_saddlepit": false }, "nature_trace": { "seed": "paretosol:nature-saddlepit:v1:batch-effect", "generator_posture": "author_the_latent_process_not_the_saddlepit_branch", "latent_mode_count": 2, "mode_story": "batch_effect_same_question_overasked_at_too_fine_grain", "latent_subpopulations": [ { "id": "batch_alpha", "pi": 0.52, "verdict_direction": 1, "xi": 0.492 }, { "id": "batch_beta", "pi": 0.48, "verdict_direction": -1, "xi": 0.508 } ], "receipt_emission": "categorical_subpopulation_then_student_t_sign_noise_with_nu_equals_ESS_weighted_by_confidence_and_decay", "clocks": [ "valid_from", "knowledge_from" ], "source_confidence_weights": { "observed": 1, "derived": 0.62, "asserted": 0.28 }, "decay_bands": [ "R0", "R1", "R2", "R3", "R4", "R5", "R6" ], "spectral_gap_curve": [ { "grain": "g_fine", "delta_g": 0.03, "leading_vector": "unstable" }, { "grain": "g_mid", "delta_g": 0.08, "leading_vector": "flipping" }, { "grain": "g_rev_fixed_point", "delta_g": 0.31, "leading_vector": "stable" } ], "moment_reads": [ { "grain": "g_fine", "resolves_subpopulations": true, "mu": 0.02, "ess": 18.4, "excess_kurtosis": 11.6, "l_kurtosis": 0.64, "dip_test": "bimodal", "spectral_gap": 0.03, "classification": "SADDLEPIT" }, { "grain": "g_rev_fixed_point", "resolves_subpopulations": false, "mu": 0.04, "ess": 21.2, "excess_kurtosis": 0.72, "l_kurtosis": 0.08, "dip_test": "unimodal", "spectral_gap": 0.31, "classification": "verdict" } ], "drain_path": [ { "grain": "g_fine", "classification": "SADDLEPIT", "excess_kurtosis": 11.6, "spectral_gap": 0.03 }, { "grain": "g_rev_fixed_point", "classification": "verdict", "excess_kurtosis": 0.72, "spectral_gap": 0.31 } ], "time_machine": [ { "knowledge_fraction": 0.25, "classification": "GHOST", "ess": 4.8, "excess_kurtosis": 7.1 }, { "knowledge_fraction": 0.55, "classification": "SADDLEPIT", "ess": 10.6, "excess_kurtosis": 10.4 }, { "knowledge_fraction": 1, "classification": "SADDLEPIT", "ess": 18.4, "excess_kurtosis": 11.6 } ], "invariants": { "drain_monotonicity": "pass", "ess_washout": "kurtosis_persists_as_ESS_grows", "sign_symmetry_null_mean": "pass", "deterministic_seed": true, "total_class_map": true, "coarsen_past_REV_drains": true }, "falsifier": "if coarsening past REV does not reduce kurtosis, the generator or REV curve is wrong" }, "review_cycle": 1, "review_due": "2026-07-04", "jurisdiction": "ctst_visual_scout_receipt_review", "declared_grain": "microtheory_boundary", "reviewers": [ "statistics", "process", "audit" ], "supersedes": null, "superseded_by": null, "observations": [ "localized contradiction pile-up", "glut-kurtosis high while mean remains low", "spectral gap of K_g collapsed", "microtheory boundary disorientation high" ], "observation_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 0, "observation": "localized contradiction pile-up", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 1, "observation": "glut-kurtosis high while mean remains low", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:spectral_gap_Kg" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 2, "observation": "spectral gap of K_g collapsed", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:percolation_guard" }, { "event": "OBSERVED", "index": 3, "observation": "microtheory boundary disorientation high", "source_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster" } ], "decision_basis": [ "low_mean_high_kurtosis", "spectral_gap_collapsed", "rev_oracle_feedback_required", "revision_damping_until_gap_restabilizes" ], "decision_explanation": "saddlepit: refuse because evidence is overfull and contradictory, not because data is merely absent", "missing_evidence": [], "next_evidence_needed": [ "nogood detector run if common-cause", "coarsen or split REV", "hold revisions until spectral gap restabilizes" ], "review_events": [ { "event": "OBSERVED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "sensor_or_fixture", "evidence_ref": "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster", "basis": "observation captured without decision authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "CLASSIFIED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "rev_oracle", "evidence_ref": "family:saddlepit", "basis": "owner=rev_oracle; grain=microtheory_boundary", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REVIEWED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "decision_basis", "basis": "low_mean_high_kurtosis; spectral_gap_collapsed; rev_oracle_feedback_required; revision_damping_until_gap_restabilizes", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "REV_FEEDBACK_REQUESTED", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "rev_oracle:coarsen_or_split", "basis": "glut-kurtosis localized and spectral gap collapsed", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" }, { "event": "SADDLEPIT", "receipt_id": "saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy", "at": "1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z", "actor": "review_board", "evidence_ref": "state:SADDLEPIT", "basis": "current posture set; no material action authority", "append_only": true, "authority_boundary": "review_event_does_not_certify_underlying_scientific_claim" } ], "thresholds": [ "glut_mean < 0.25 and glut_kurtosis >= 8 => early saddlepit alarm", "spectral_gap <= 0.05 => REV near-degeneracy", "percolation_margin <= 0.20 => decidable-surface disconnection risk" ], "receipt_refs": [ "receipt:saddlepit:contradiction_cluster", "receipt:saddlepit:spectral_gap_Kg", "receipt:saddlepit:percolation_guard" ], "scout_band_posture": "not_truth" } ] }, "console": "cTST SADDLESCOPE\nSaddlescope turns uncertainty into an auditable object.\ncontract=pinto_ctst_saddlescope/v1\nq/kappa/MEO are scout bands, not truth\nno material permission or action authority\ngovernance process: intake -> triage -> evidence review -> board review -> action items -> re-review -> audit\nabsence ontology: VOID / GHOST / verdict / SADDLEPIT\nnature generator: author latent process, not a saddlepit branch\nsaddlepit signal: low mean + high kurtosis + collapsed spectral gap requests REV feedback\nstates=SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE, WITHHELD, REJECTED, OPEN, SADDLEPIT\ncounts=SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE:2 WITHHELD:2 REJECTED:1 OPEN:2 SADDLEPIT:1\nlayers=observations -> derived scout bands -> workflow decision\n- permission_direct_coupon_bridge permission SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE q=0.68 kappa=0.61 MEO=0.74\n owner=materials review_cycle=3 review_due=2026-07-28 grain=coupon_bridge reviewers=materials,statistics\n May this reviewed coupon bridge be used as a scout exemplar?\n observations: identity continuity PASS; REV PASS; jurisdiction PASS; topology conflicts none\n decision_basis: identity_continuity_pass; scope_bounded; redaction_clean; no_material_action_authority\n decision_explanation: scope-bounded, redaction-clean receipt is admissible to the scout wall\n next_evidence_needed: replicate coupon; owner boundary refresh\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> NEW_EVIDENCE -> REVIEWED -> SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE\n absence_kind=verdict rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n- evidence_interface_gap evidence WITHHELD q=0.44 kappa=0.36 MEO=0.52\n owner=process review_cycle=2 review_due=2026-07-16 grain=interface reviewers=materials,process\n Is the interface gap backed by enough receipt density?\n observations: one microscopy trace; interface A/B bridge not characterized\n decision_basis: interface_bridge_missing; replicate_count_below_threshold; owner_boundary_absent\n decision_explanation: withheld until second receipt closes variance\n next_evidence_needed: second microscopy receipt; replicate coupon; owner boundary\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> REVIEWED -> WITHHELD\n absence_kind=GHOST rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n missing: second microscopy receipt; owner boundary; interface bridge characterization\n- ladder_half_rev_jump ladder OPEN q=0.51 kappa=0.47 MEO=0.58\n owner=statistics review_cycle=1 review_due=2026-07-08 grain=REV_half_rung reviewers=statistics,materials\n Does half REV explain the observed scale transition?\n observations: declared grain coupon; observed grain interface band; REV delta crosses one half-rung\n decision_basis: declared_grain_coupon; observed_grain_interface_band; half_rev_delta_detected; recrossing_untested\n decision_explanation: open because recrossing survival is untested; half marks a partial REV grain shift, not a promotion\n next_evidence_needed: recrossing survival check; grain repeat receipt\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> REVIEWED -> OPEN\n absence_kind=GHOST rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n- open_axis_formula_owner open_axis OPEN q=0.29 kappa=0.22 MEO=0.41\n owner=governance review_cycle=1 review_due=2026-07-08 grain=authority_axis reviewers=process,audit\n Which owner can close the formula axis?\n observations: formula owner absent; rule predicate absent; freshness bounded\n decision_basis: authority_owner_unknown; rule_predicate_absent; review_question_must_stay_visible\n decision_explanation: open because the authority owner is unknown and the question must stay visible to reviewers\n next_evidence_needed: named owner; rule predicate; freshness receipt refresh\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> REVIEWED -> OPEN\n absence_kind=GHOST rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n missing: named owner; rule predicate; freshness receipt refresh\n- active_meo_metric_inversion active_meo REJECTED q=0.18 kappa=0.14 MEO=0.33\n owner=statistics review_cycle=2 review_due=2026-07-23 grain=metric_path reviewers=statistics,process\n Can the candidate MEO be treated as explanatory?\n observations: expected monotonicity depth -> modulus; observed inversion at edge band; route recrosses\n decision_basis: expected_monotonicity_declared; observed_metric_inversion; threshold_breached; negative_control_retained\n decision_explanation: rejected, but retained as negative control\n next_evidence_needed: repeat metric path; alternate coordinate check\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> REVIEWED -> REJECTED\n absence_kind=verdict rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n- topology_cycle_current topology WITHHELD q=0.56 kappa=0.39 MEO=0.49\n owner=process review_cycle=2 review_due=2026-07-16 grain=topology_cycle reviewers=statistics,process\n Does the topology carry a true detailed-balance break?\n observations: cycle substrate present; entropy production positive; eigenvector alignment thin\n decision_basis: residual_eigenvector_disagreement; local_topology_not_global_coordinate_authority; coordinate_lens_review_missing\n decision_explanation: withheld because residual and eigenvector checks disagree\n next_evidence_needed: residual agreement; eigenvector agreement; coordinate-lens review\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> REVIEWED -> WITHHELD\n absence_kind=GHOST rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n missing: residual agreement; eigenvector agreement; coordinate-lens review\n- matsci_nylon_ceramic_coupon matsci SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE q=0.73 kappa=0.66 MEO=0.69\n owner=materials review_cycle=3 review_due=2026-07-28 grain=coupon_interface reviewers=materials,statistics,process\n May MatSci coupon receipts seed the visual scout?\n observations: coupon nylon_ceramic_002 scanned; moisture uptake band bounded; material class nylon ceramic bridge\n decision_basis: coupon_receipt_present; material_family_declared; certification_claim_absent; no_material_action_authority\n decision_explanation: scout-admissible; not a material certificate\n next_evidence_needed: replicate coupon; method uncertainty receipt\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> NEW_EVIDENCE -> REVIEWED -> SCOUT_ADMISSIBLE\n absence_kind=verdict rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n- saddlepit_rev_near_degeneracy saddlepit SADDLEPIT q=0.37 kappa=0.19 MEO=0.64\n owner=rev_oracle review_cycle=1 review_due=2026-07-04 grain=microtheory_boundary reviewers=statistics,process,audit\n Is this region undecidable because evidence is missing, or because too much contradictory evidence piled up?\n observations: localized contradiction pile-up; glut-kurtosis high while mean remains low; spectral gap of K_g collapsed; microtheory boundary disorientation high\n decision_basis: low_mean_high_kurtosis; spectral_gap_collapsed; rev_oracle_feedback_required; revision_damping_until_gap_restabilizes\n decision_explanation: saddlepit: refuse because evidence is overfull and contradictory, not because data is merely absent\n next_evidence_needed: nogood detector run if common-cause; coarsen or split REV; hold revisions until spectral gap restabilizes\n review_events: OBSERVED -> CLASSIFIED -> REVIEWED -> REV_FEEDBACK_REQUESTED -> SADDLEPIT\n absence_kind=SADDLEPIT rev_oracle_version=rev_oracle:grain_lattice:v0.1.11\n saddlepit: mean=0.18 kurtosis=11.6 spectral_gap=0.03 percolation_margin=0.17\n nature_seed=paretosol:nature-saddlepit:v1:batch-effect generator_posture=author_the_latent_process_not_the_saddlepit_branch\n nature_read=g_fine:SADDLEPIT:kurtosis=11.6:ESS=18.4 -> g_rev_fixed_point:verdict:kurtosis=0.72:ESS=21.2\n rev_feedback=coarsen_or_split_requested cause=rev_near_degeneracy\nDo not treat q, kappa, or MEO bands as truth, material certification, or permission to act.\n", "live_demo": { "route": "/ctst/saddlescope", "public_beta": "/beta", "mcp_endpoint": "/mcp", "boundary": "hash_safe_receipts_only_no_material_permission_no_truth_claim" } }